Emily Murphy And The Persons Case Essay

The Persons Case and Womens Right to Vote in Canada


{The Vote: Suffragists were relentless campaigners, lecturers, demonstrators and petitioners. They bravely faced politicians' ire and the aggressive opposition of public opinion. By 1918, some women were granted the right to vote and to have a say in the political future of Canada. For many other women, their race, ethnicity and religion still barred them from the vote and, for them, the fight continued for almost 50 years. It wasn't until the introduction of the Universal Right to Vote in 1963 and the addition of the equality clause in the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms in 1985 that the right to vote could not be denied on the basis of race, national or ethnic origin, colour, religion, age, mental or physical disability, or gender.}


The "Famous Five" and the Persons Case:


Early activists challenge conventional views to change Canadian history ==èThe Famous Five achieved not only the right for women to serve in the Senate, but they and their many contributions paved the way for women to participate in other aspects of public life and the assertion of women's rights ==èEmily Murphy, Louise McKinney, Irene Parlby, Nellie McClung, Henrietta Muir Edwards



"We want women leaders today as never before. Leaders who are not afraid to be called names and who are willing to go out and fight. I think women can save civilization. Women are persons."


- Emily Murphy - 1931


The early 20th century and the courageous women who challenged the existing status of women are now part of the historic landscape of Canada. Five women created legal history in women's rights by contesting the notion that legal definitions of persons excluded females. If women were not legally persons, then they had no rights.


The women who pursued the petition were journalists, magistrates or politicians. Their legal quest reached the highest level of appeals, the British Privy Council, which ultimately pronounced women "persons". It is a notable victory for equal rights.


The determination and dedication of these remarkable women is honored by The Governor General's Awards in Commemoration of the Persons Case. In 1979 on the 50th anniversary of the decree that women were 'persons' the Canadian government struck the first medal. It is the only tribute to those who work to promote gender equality and the full participation of women in the economic fabric of the country.


Reform movements attract support


The early 1900s in the Canadian west were turbulent and rapidly changing times. In Alberta, the population began to shift from a strictly rural to an increasing urban one. Men outnumbered women three to two. These situations combined to create what some perceived as significant social problems of alcohol abuse and prostitution.


Women began to organize and support those organizations dedidated to 'cleaning up society'. At the same time, women began to seek a larger role in politics. In 1916, the Alberta legislature passed legislation granting women the right to vote.


The British North America Act of 1867 set out the powers and responsibilities of the provinces and of the federal government. This federal act used the word "persons" when it referred to more than one person and the word "he" when it referred to one person. Therefore, many argued, the Act was really saying that only a man could be a person, thus preventing women from participating fully in politics or affairs of state.


This situation was of concern to Canada's Emily Murphy, the first woman magistrate in the British Empire. Judge Murphy was the magistrate of a newly created Women's Court operating in Edmonton. On her first day a defendant's lawyer challenged a ruling, because she was not a "person" and therefore, not qualified to perform the duties of a magistrate.


Magistrate Alice Jamieson of Calgary found herself similarly challenged. In 1917 one of her rulings was appealed to the Alberta Supreme Court, which deemed that there was no legal disqualification for holding public office in the government based on sex.


At the same time, women's groups began pressuring the federal government to appoint a woman to the Senate. Despite the support of Prime Ministers Arthur Meighen and William Lyon MacKenzie King, no appointments materialized. Governments used the persons argument as the excuse used to keep women out of important positions, like the Senate. If only a man could be a person, then when the Act also said only "qualified persons" could be appointed to the Senate of Canada, then only men could be appointed to the Senate.


The five who became famous


In 1927 Emily Murphy and four other prominent Canadian women - Nellie McClung, Irene Parlby, Louise McKinney and Henrietta Muir Edwards - asked the Supreme Court of Canada to answer the question, "Does the word "person" in Section 24 of the B.N.A. Act include female persons?" After five weeks of debate and argument the Supreme Court of Canada decided that the word "person" did not include women.


The five women, nicknamed "The Famous Five", were shocked by the Supreme Court decision but did not give up the fight. Instead they refused to accept the decision and took the Persons Case to the Privy Council in England which in those days was Canada's highest court.


The Privy Council decides

On October 18, 1929, Lord Sankey, Lord Chancellor of the Privy council, announced the decision of the five Lords. The decision stated "that the exclusion of women from all public offices is a relic of days more barbarous than ours. And to those who would ask why the word "person" should include females, the obvious answer is, why should it not?"


The Famous Five achieved not only the right for women to serve in the Senate, but they and their many contributions paved the way for women to participate in other aspects of public life and the assertion of women's rights is now honoured by the Governor General's Awards in Commemoration of the Persons Case.


The "Famous Five":

Emily Murphy, Louise McKinney, Irene Parlby, Nellie McClung, Henrietta Muir Edwards



Emily Murphy



"Whenever I don't know whether to fight or not, I fight."

Born in Cookstown, Ontario, Emily (Ferguson) Murphy was already an accomplished author by the time she arrived in Edmonton in 1907. A mother of two, she spearheaded campaigns for women's property rights, and in 1916 she was the first woman in the British Empire to be appointed as a police magistrate. During this time, a lawyer repeatedly challenged her rulings, claiming that she was not legally a "person." In 1927 she led the legal challenge now known as the Persons Case.


Louise McKinney



"The purpose of a woman's life is just the same as the purpose of a man's life: that she may make the best possible contribution to her generation."

Louise (Crummy) McKinney raged against the evils of alcohol and the "disabilities laid on women" and played a leading role in bringing Alberta women the right to vote in 1916. She was the first woman sworn in to the Alberta Legislature and the first in any Legislature in the British Empire. As an MLA, elected in 1917 to represent Claresholm, she worked to inititate social assistance measures for widows and immigrants and, along with Emily Murphy, helped establish the Dower Act, allowing women property rights in marriage.


Irene Parlby



"Evolution cannot be brought about by the use of dynamite."

Born in London, England, Irene (Marryat) Parlby came to Alberta in 1896, married a rancher, and settled in the Lacombe area. She was elected to the Alberta Legislature in 1921 under the United Farmers of Alberta banner and helped push through 18 bills to improve the plight of women and children. She was named to cabinet as a minister without portfolio in 1921, only the second woman cabinet minister in the British Empire. She was president of the United Farm Women of Alberta and a staunch advocate for rural Alberta women.


Nellie McClung



"Never retract, never explain, never apologize - get things done and let them howl."

Novelist, legislator, prohibitionist, and suffragette, Nellie (Mooney) McClung's influence was felt across the prairies. The Chatsworth, Ontario-born school teacher helped Manitoba women win the right to vote and continued the battle in Alberta after arriving in Edmonton in 1914. She was elected to the Alberta Legislature as an opposition Liberal in 1921, was the first woman on the CBC Board of Governors, a representative to the League of Nations, a Sunday school teacher, and a mother of five.


Henrietta Muir Edwards



"We sought to establish the individuality of women... It was an uphill fight."

Henrietta (Muir) Edwards was active in prison reform, organized the forerunner to the YWCA in Montreal in 1875 to provide vocational training for impoverished working women, and published and financed the first Canadian magazine for working women. A student of law, she helped establish the National Council of Women in 1890 and served for decades as its convenor of laws. She wrote several books on the legal status of women and compiled a list of provincial laws affecting women and children across Canada at the request of the federal government.


Emily Murphy: Canadian Women's Rights Activist

Emily Murphy: Canadian Women's Rights Activist

It was only in this century that women in Canada had equal rights as
men. But this would never happen if women themselves would not start
fighting for their rights. One of these women was Emily Murphy and her
greatest achievement, Emily proved that women are `persons' and therefore
they have the right to work in any political office. Her life and
political career lead her to this achievement.

Emily Gowan Ferguson was born on March 14, 1868 in a village of
Cookstown. It was Uncle Thomas who was a politician and who influenced
Emily's interest in politics. At fifteen Emily moved to Toronto and
attended the Bishop Strachan School for Girls. Emily married Reverend
Arthur Murphy in 1887 in Anglican church of St. John's in Cookstown and in
1904 she and her husband moved to Winnipeg. Mrs. Murphy "conducted the
literary section of the Winnipeg Tribune for a few years before moving to
Alberta in 1907." In her new home Emily became very active in civic
affairs especially in law that would improve the rights of women and

In 1900's in Alberta any man who, for example, had a farm and was
married could sell that farm and leave his wife and children walking away
with the money. Mrs. Murphy was angry that Alberta would allow such
disgrace. In 1910 Emily was still fighting for the Dower Act "which would
recognize a married woman's entitlement to a share of the common property
in a marriage". For the first time the act was turned down, Emily not
giving up tried very hard until 1911 when Dower Act was passed. "It
provided that a wife must get a third of her husband's estate, even when he
did not leave a will." It was a major victory for Emily and also her first
achievement. This accomplishment not only encouraged women to fight for
their rights but Emily gained new confidence and encouraged her to fight
for new suffrage bill. In 1914 Mrs. Murphy and Mrs. McClung joined forces
and in 1916 after long negotiations a suffrage bill was introduced to the
legislature. Because of the war now ranging in Europe "there was an even
greater sense of urgency for women's suffrage, and Murphy - McClung team
doubled its efforts". The first session in February 24,...

Loading: Checking Spelling


Read more

Women Rights in Canada Essay

1285 words - 5 pages “Honey, you’re not a person, now get back in the kitchen and make me a sandwich!” If a husband were to say these words to his wife today, he would likely receive a well-deserved smack to the face. It is not until recently that Canadian women have received their status as people and obtained equal rights as men. Women were excluded from an academic education and received a lesser pay than their male counter parts. With the many hardships women had...

Canada in the 1920's Essay

1937 words - 8 pages PoliticalAfter the first world war Canada started to become more independent from the British empire. At the imperial conference in 1921, prime minister Arthur Meighen opposed a British plan for renewing the alliance with Japan. This decision was based strongly on the American opposition. In 1922, a diplomatic crisis occurred in Turkey, the Canadians did...

Women Taking Action

1552 words - 6 pages The 1920s were one of the biggest time changes around the world to everyone. People had more freedom and seemed to have more fun. Inventions advanced such as the significance of electricity which helped extend time for work and fun. Even the radio changed the lives of everyone by bringing people together through communication, jokes, and music. While everything else was changing in the 1920s the women were also changing by their style of...

Nellie McClung

1641 words - 7 pages         Helen 'Nellie' Laetitia Mooney was born October 20, 1873 in a log cabin on Garafraxa Road, two kilometers from Chatsworth, Ontario. She and her family moved to Manitoba when she was six years old.         One of Nellie's best influences was her mother. Her family's influence was no doubt the reason she became an activist. Her mother thought that every child had the right to an education, and her whole family...


589 words - 2 pages The differing forms of communication by the two aunts play a role in Naomi's lifestyle choice: Obasan with her use of Japanese silence and Emily through her straight forwardness. Obasan lives her life through a shell that traps her thoughts and feelings inside. She expresses her feelings in her actions and with occasional Japanese phrases. This is evident in the following...

Negative Effects of the Increased Rights for Women in Canada

902 words - 4 pages Geronga 1Alvie A. GerongaCOMM170-311Professor Emily DonvilleJuly 24, 2009Negative Effects of the Increased Rights for Women in CanadaWhy this difference between men and women? When natural selection shaped male-female differences, it didn't stop at muscles and naughty bits. It also shaped differences in...

Negative Effects of the Increased Rights for Women in Canada

902 words - 4 pages Geronga 1Alvie A. GerongaCOMM170-311Professor Emily DonvilleJuly 24, 2009Negative Effects of the Increased Rights for Women in CanadaWhy this difference between men and women? When natural selection shaped male-female differences, it didn't stop at muscles and naughty bits. It also shaped differences in...

This is an essay about people, groups, and government actions which aided Canada's minority groups from 1960-1980.

1730 words - 7 pages IntroductionThesis: There is no doubt that the three factors identified below were the key to successes achieved by Canada's minority groups during the 1960s through to the 1980s.Criteria: A. The first criterion that will be covered in this essay is the impact ofvarious people belonging to these minority groups, and how theycontributed to helping their...

Harriet Tubman and Emily Murphy- Exploring Attributes of Great Leaders

1499 words - 6 pages Every leader had to start somewhere; they all had to have a reason to become a great leader. They have developed strong attributes to overcome their struggles and challenges. Great leaders like Harriet Tubman and Emily Murphy, who have had the courage to take action in the world and have had great confidence to achieve their goals. They are among the people, who through centuries have made a difference. Who have fought for their rights and...

My Great-Grandmother was not a Person

631 words - 3 pages My Great-Grandmother was not a Person My Great-Grandmother was not a person. Neither was yours. Up until about 67 years ago no females were. We were supposed to be pregnant and barefoot in the kitchen. At least that's the perception that the laws enforced. (For ex: The Election Act of the Dominion of Canada and The Common Law of England) As part of the British Commonwealth many of our laws were the same as England's and enforced by...

The Women's Rights Movement 1848-1920

1363 words - 5 pages The Women’s Rights Movement was a long and persistent battle fought by many brave female advocates that came before us such as Elizabeth Cady Stanton, Lucretia Mott and Susan B. Anthony. These women selflessly dedicated their lives to the ratification of the 19th Amendment, which forever changed the lives of womankind in America. Prior to their efforts, the United States was still in shambles over the Civil War and spent most of its focus on...

0 Replies to “Emily Murphy And The Persons Case Essay”

Lascia un Commento

L'indirizzo email non verrà pubblicato. I campi obbligatori sono contrassegnati *